Tesla rebounds as Morgan Stanley says sell-off gone too far

AFTER losing nearly US$300 billion (RM1.35 trillion) in market value in two months, a growing chorus of Tesla Inc analysts say the share-price decline has gone far enough, pushing the stock higher on Nov 23. 

Morgan Stanley analyst Adam Jonas earlier said that Tesla is approaching his “bear case” price target of US$150, presenting an opportunity for investors to Buyat a bargain price. Citi analysts upgraded the shares to Neutralfrom Sell, saying that a more than 50% slump this year “has balanced out the near-term risk/reward”. 

Despite challenges including decelerating demand and price cuts in China, Tesla is the only electric vehicle maker covered by Morgan Stanley that generates a profit on the sale of its cars, Jonas wrote in a note. The analyst — who also highlighted Tesla’s potential to benefit from consumer tax credits in the US — reiterated his US$330 price target. 

Shares closed up 7.8% at US$183.20 in New York on Nov 23. The stock has slumped this year amid rising raw materials costs, issues with production and sales in China and pressure on customer budgets. Latterly, CEO Elon Musk’s focus on turning around Twitter Inc has also hit sentiment, with US$300 billion wiped o Tesla’s market cap in the past two months, according to Bloomberg calculations. 

The distraction caused by Twitter needs to end to stop the stock slide, according to Jonas. “There must be some form of sentiment ‘circuit breaker’ around the Twitter situation to calm investor concerns around Tesla,” he wrote. 

Despite all of the challenges Tesla has faced this year, Wall Street has mainly stayed bullish. The majority of Tesla analysts tracked by Bloomberg rate the stock a buy or equivalent, while the shares would need to rally a whopping 57% to hit the average analyst target price. This year’s slump has le$ the stock trading at 31 times forward earnings, down from more than 200 times in early 2021. 

Citi analyst Itay Michaeli, who upgraded the stock on Nov 23, has one of the lowest price targets on the Street, at US$176. The analyst said he was turning more positive because Tesla’s slump means that some of the overly-bullish expectations in the stock, including on unit sales, have now been priced out. — Bloomberg 

  • This article first appeared in The Malaysian Reserve weekly print edition