Lufthansa pits Boeing 787 against A350


FRANKFURT • Deutsche Lufthansa AG is trying to decide whether to take its first Boeing Co 787 Dreamliners, or to expand its fleet of Airbus SE’s marquee A350 wide-body jets as it updates its long-range aircraft, according to people familiar with the plans.

Lufthansa has requested proposals from both Airbus and Boeing, and is looking to order about 20 jets in a deal that may be finalised in the next few months, said the people, who asked not to be identified as the discussions are private.

The campaign to woo an influential blue-chip customer will probably hinge on more than the customary discounts for a deal valued at about US$5 billion (RM20.8 billion) at list prices. The German airline is also asking the planemakers to help it get rid of its aging and fuel-hungry Airbus A340 models, the people said.

Representatives of Lufthansa, Airbus and Boeing declined to comment.

While Boeing and Airbus have on occasion taken back used jets to seal deals, they probably wouldn’t consider A340 trade-ins from just any potential buyer, said George Ferguson, an analyst with Bloomberg Intelligence.

Demand and book values for the four-engine aircraft have dwindled as airlines shifted to flying more-efficient twin-engine models.

“It depends on the customer, the price people want on that asset,” Ferguson said. “If you have A340s, you’re pretty motivated to get them off the books in a way that makes it palatable to shareholders.”

Lufthansa has already ordered 25 A350s, 12 of which will operate in Munich by yearend, and holds options for 30 more. While it has vowed to reduce fleet complexity, five years ago the carrier ordered 34 Boeing 777-9 jets, with the first one due to arrive in 2020. Those would be on top of any potential order for the smaller 787s.

The Boeing 777-9 deal has come under internal scrutiny, and Lufthansa has said it is considering stretching out deliveries, concerned about the cost and size of what will be the industry’s largest-ever twin-engine jetliner. The accord includes 14 jets that Lufthansa can opt out of taking.

Lufthansa’s fleet includes almost 100 four-engine aircraft, which produce the highest fuel bill of any airline in Europe. Its A340s, almost a fifth of the models still in operation worldwide, are increasingly a liability with oil prices near the highest in about four years. The oldest -300s, delivered between 1996 and 2001, are considered likelier candidates for retirement over the stretched -600s, some of which are less than a decade old.